With the middle season dropped, and the massive amount of reviews online (most in unison) i decided to review a few things about this show rather than wait until it finishes. Now I will say that at least after the first 4 episodes the show still keeps me hooked and waiting for each week´s release, no matter if i enjoy or not the episode as a whole. There are a few topics i want to share my thoughts first. I want to say that even with a few things that i don't like yet, i liked the show so far, more than "Kenobi" or even "BoBF"

1) Ki Adi Mundi dillema: The choice of Ki Adi was not the best of all, especially if they will bring more "cameos" (since the 180 mill there could be a few more). First of all, the idea of Mundi hiding information from the Council itself, he would have never got that position in the first place. Yes, he is perhaps the most disliked jedi from the prequels, but that doesn´t mean that "the sith have gone extint for a milllenuim" works with his new appereance in the show.

2) Kids now being important to the Jedi: Back then, it was established not just in the Prequels (main canon though, not just source) and expanded content that there was a max. age for a kid to be trained, hence the conflict in Episode I with Anakin not being taken in consideration by the Jedi Council. Now two girls from outer space, being way older than Anakin being taken by the Jedi? Idk, i am not a fan of that, it doesn´t work for me.

3) "Sith Lord": There are 2 possibilities of this character, and who may it be: The main obvious one is Jacinto's character Quimir, very suspicius and each cut or dissapereance of the character works in favour of him being the SL. The other is one of the witches, the zabrak one, that shows very 2dark side" tendencies and was against the jedi from the beggining. It could also tie with the Nightsisters in a way (and Dathomir, at least maybe she was part of it). Last one, a character we don't expect, perhaps a jedi itself.

4) Not a sith Master... Abeloth? I would probably be wrong about this, just like Ahsoka (parcially, that last scene of Baylan still leaves some possibilities) but i would prefer if she is the one behind the "new apprendice" rather than some like "knights of Ren" sect or even Plagueis (i am not sure and don´t think Plagueis is going to be done great in this show if they bring him in, an issue i see with LF a lot, changing characters that we know)

5) Cast: A little about this, but they wasted a lot of them already. I can see the choice of Moss just to promote the show rather than gave her a prominent role. Same to the death of the jedi wookie (Joonas Suotamo As Kelnacca) and not having even a proper fight vs the apprendice.

6) "Change of heart": Again with this, a dark side or "evil" character switch sides in a very anticlimatic way. Not much to say yet, since perhaps there is something behing this that i didn´t get in the first 4 eps, but like cmon, wait until the end. Now the "bad one" doesn't have other choice but to kill ker; or perhaps take the other twin.

7) The power of... I don´t want to see that scene again haha jk. But real, it didn´t work for me. The twins being borned and created by this "thread" doesn´t work, so that means that Plagueis, big Emperor Palpatine, all the Sith failed while a few witches make it out? and Anakin.. Is he not special anymore? He is THE CHOSEN ONE for a reason. Making these 2 like this doesn't work..

8) TLJ 2.0: The 3rd episode definitely reminded me of that movie, of course not a pleasant one, but in the same way RJ made the plot: Flashback of scenes told by a certain perspective (in this case, Osha, the mechanic one), a new "concept" of the force as a "threat" that is against what GL believes, etc. So much that broke it down.

9) Witches everywhere: I can see the influence of Dave in this, as much as i don´t like it. I think it´s time that we move away from them for a while. I am not saying that Nightsisters are bad, but too much witchcraft is not beneficial.

10) Twins: Not much to say, but there is no comparison to the rest of them. I missed a few, but the point still remains. Not compelling at all, probably bc of the script, as there are few lines of dialogue that could be better to flesh out the character and not making it weird in a way.

11) How it would make sense: Now there are a lot of questions, so the first thing for sure is that at least everybody that saw the red lightsaber HAS TO DIE, or either way expelled or leave the jedi order itself (by being treat as a liar, etc.). You have to make it work with the lore pre established in the Prequels, we can´t have Sith or "Dark Jedi" with red lightsabers roaming around. There is also the bleeding of the crystal, or they missed that? Idk, i will wait until it finishes to review it properly. But the fandom has decided, and Disney once again with splitting everything into two sides again.

Leaving now, and i will add that the fights need some work, this is pre peak jedi. I get that maybe the jedi became more "docile" since there are no big enemies yet (didn't read HR, i am not sure the level of threat the Nihre or what they called them are).